Behind on Payments · With Chris Moore

Selling a Newer Home in Clay County: Mortgage Relief and Auction Lessons

A newer Clay County home with a payment one income cannot carry, how Florida foreclosure timing and your options work, what to know about tax deed auction houses and code liens, and how to check a For Sale By Owner sign.

The Short Version

I made three stops in Clay County. A mom on her own has a newer home with a payment she can no longer carry. Then a warning about tax deed auction houses, where some government liens survive the sale. Then a For Sale By Owner sign I checked against the owner of record. Below I add the Florida rules behind each stop, with sources and data dates, plus a checklist you can use. This is general information, not legal or financial advice.

A Newer Home That Got Too Expensive for One Income

The first stop in this video was a newer build, early 2020s, in a community off Blanding Boulevard. By my own count I have sold about six homes in that community over the years, so it is a part of Clay County I know well.

The owner is a mom raising two kids on her own, with a small dog. She told me she tried to help a family member by letting that person stay in the home. The family member was supposed to make the mortgage payments and did not. She had to put a lot of her own money in to catch the loan back up. That left her stretched, and the monthly payment is now more than one income can carry.

She had already talked to a couple of other agents when I got there. I came in wearing two hats, as a licensed agent and as a buyer. That matters, because it means I can lay out a listing and a direct sale side by side. I do not have to push one answer.

A newer house does not mean an easy situation. The house is in good shape. The problem is the monthly number, and nobody can fix that with fresh paint.

The plan we talked through

Here is what we discussed, in plain terms. It is one option, not the only one.

  • Find an affordable rental for her, her two kids and her dog first, so she knows where they are going.
  • I buy the house, fix it up and put it back on the market.
  • She gets out from under a payment that is not working, rebuilds her credit over a couple of years and buys again when she is ready.

I did not quote numbers on camera, and I will not in this article either. Every house and every loan is different. What I will do below is show you the Florida rules and the local market data so you can judge any offer you get, from me or anyone else.

The same visit had two other stops that taught me something, a tax deed auction warning and a For Sale By Owner sign. I cover both later in this article.

What the Clay County Market Looks Like Right Now

Before you decide how to sell, it helps to know what the market is doing. Here is the latest data I could confirm from primary sources.

Selected market data, as of October 2026
MeasureFigureData date and source
Clay County single-family median price$355,000, down 4.1%September 2026, released Oct 8, 2026 (NEFAR, Fleming Island Orange Park Times)
Clay County median days on market48 daysSeptember 2026 (NEFAR, Times)
Clay County closed sales and active listings219 closed, 954 active, a 4.4 month supplySeptember 2026 (NEFAR, Times)
30 year fixed mortgage rate, national average7.32%, down from 7.40% the week beforeWeek ending Oct 22, 2026 (Freddie Mac, FRED)

Two things stand out to me. First, the median Clay County home spent 48 days on the market in September. Your own house may be faster or slower. Second, the national 30 year rate was 7.32% in late October, which is higher than the 6.19% Freddie Mac reported a year earlier (Freddie Mac). In my experience, higher rates make buyers more careful, so a seller who needs to move quickly should think about timing as well as price.

A word of caution. NEFAR is the local Realtor association, so it is a trade group. A median is a midpoint, not a promise about your house. Please do not read $355,000 as what your home is worth. A fair opinion of value looks at your street, your condition and recent sales near you.

How Florida Foreclosure Timing Works

The mom in this video was not in foreclosure when I met her, and I am not saying she would be. But a lot of homeowners who carry a payment that is too high wonder how much time they have. So here is how the timeline works, from official sources.

The federal 120 day rule

Under the federal servicing rule, a mortgage servicer generally may not make the first notice or filing for a foreclosure unless the loan is more than 120 days delinquent (CFPB, 12 CFR 1024.41(f)). The CFPB explains it the same way in plain language: the legal foreclosure process cannot start until you are at least 120 days behind (CFPB). The rule has exceptions, such as a foreclosure based on a due-on-sale clause. The CFPB also says that once the servicer starts the legal process, the time to an actual sale varies by state.

The CFPB's advice if you are struggling is simple. Act quickly, respond when your servicer contacts you, and ask about loss mitigation programs. A HUD-approved housing counseling agency can walk you through the process for free. The CFPB lists (855) 411-2372 as the number to be connected to one (CFPB).

If a lawsuit is filed

In Florida, a foreclosure is a court case. Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.140(a)(1) says a defendant must serve an answer within 20 days after service of the original process and the initial pleading, unless a statute sets a different time (Rule 1.140). Florida Law Help says you must file a written response within 20 days of receiving the summons and complaint, and that if you do not, the lender may automatically win (Florida Law Help). The Duval County Clerk says the same: 20 calendar days from service, and a default can be entered if you do not respond (Duval Clerk).

That 20 day window is short. If you are served, talk to a Florida attorney or a legal aid office right away.

The right to cure before the sale

Section 45.0315 gives a mortgagor a right to redeem. At any time before the later of the clerk filing a certificate of sale or the time set in the judgment, the mortgagor or a holder of a subordinate interest may cure the debt and stop the sale by paying the amount specified in the judgment. Otherwise, there is no right of redemption (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov).

In plain terms, there is a deadline after which the door closes. If you are thinking about selling the house to avoid a foreclosure sale, the closing has to happen with enough room to spare. That is one reason I tell people to call early.

Your Options When the Payment Is Too Much

Here are the main paths I see homeowners compare. None of them is right for everybody. This table is general information, so confirm the details for your own loan.

Common options for a payment you cannot carry
OptionWhat it isWhat to watch for
Ask your servicer for helpLoss mitigation programs the servicer may offer, such as a modificationNot guaranteed. Florida Law Help notes the court cannot force a modification (Florida Law Help). Keep everything in writing.
List with an agentA traditional sale at market valueTime on market, showings, repairs and agent and closing costs. See the numbers section below.
Sell directly to a cash buyerA private sale, often as-is, on a timeline you pickThe price is usually below a fully prepared retail sale. Compare offers, and check who is buying and whether they are licensed or insured where that applies.
Short saleA sale for less than you owe, with lender approvalThe CFPB says you will have to leave and should ask the lender to waive any deficiency in writing (CFPB).
Deed in lieu of foreclosureYou voluntarily turn the home over to the lender to avoid foreclosureMake sure it covers the entire amount you owe (CFPB). For FHA loans, federal rules require the loan to be in default and the mortgage satisfied of record (24 CFR 203.357).

What about the deficiency?

If a house sells for less than the loan balance, the gap is called a deficiency. The CFPB says that in states where you can be responsible for a deficiency, you should get a waiver in writing before you go through with a short sale (CFPB). Florida has a specific rule. Under section 702.06, for owner-occupied residential property the deficiency may not exceed the difference between the judgment amount, or in a short sale the outstanding debt, and the fair market value of the property on the date of sale. The statute also presumes a property is owner-occupied if it had a homestead exemption in the latest certified roll before the foreclosure was filed (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov). An attorney can tell you how that applies to you.

Why I lay out more than one option

When I sit down with someone, I would rather show a listing and a direct sale next to each other than tell them what to do. My own site has a cash offer vs listing calculator so you can plug in your own numbers. A direct sale can be quicker and simpler. A listing can bring a higher price if you have the time and the house is ready. Which is better depends on how much time you have, what shape the house is in and what you owe.

Running Your Own Numbers

When you compare a listing to a direct sale, two Florida closing costs are easy to forget. Both are set by official sources, so you can check them.

Documentary stamp tax on the deed

Florida charges documentary stamp tax on deeds. Section 201.02 sets the rate at 70 cents on each $100 of the consideration. The Department of Revenue says the same rate applies to most counties, with Miami-Dade as the exception (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov, Florida DOR). The Department of Revenue also says any party to a taxable deed, the seller or the buyer, is liable for the tax unless that party is exempt (DOR FAQ). In practice, the sales contract usually says who pays it, so read that part of your contract.

The math box below shows the arithmetic with a made-up round number. It is not a quote for your house.

Owner's title insurance

Title insurance rates in Florida are set by rule 69O-186.003 of the Florida Administrative Code. For an owner's policy, the rate is $5.75 per $1,000 for the first $100,000 and $5.00 per $1,000 from $100,000 up to $1 million, with a $100 minimum (Fla. Admin. Code, Florida CFO). The CFO also says a reissue rate applies if a prior owner's policy exists, so your actual number can be lower (Florida CFO).

The math box below shows the arithmetic with the same made-up number. It is arithmetic from the published rate, not a quote. Who pays for the owner's policy is set in the contract, so ask your title company for your specific figure.

The other costs

A traditional listing also has agent compensation, which is negotiable, plus repairs you agree to make, carrying costs while you wait and any concessions. A direct sale often has fewer of those, and a lower price. I will not guess a percentage here because it depends on the deal. The point is to line up every line item on both sides and compare what you net, not just the headline price.

A Warning About Tax Deed Auction Houses

Later in the video I turned the camera on a different topic that I get asked about a lot. People see a house at a county tax deed auction with a low opening bid and think they have found a deal. Sometimes they have. Sometimes the house comes with problems that the bid does not show.

How a tax deed sale happens in Florida

Taxes become delinquent on April 1 following the year they were assessed (section 197.333, flsenate.gov). The Clay County Clerk's page says that if taxes are not paid by the end of May following the taxable year, the Tax Collector sells a tax certificate, which is held for a minimum of two years and a maximum of seven (Clay Clerk). Under section 197.502, the holder of the certificate may apply for a tax deed once two years have passed since April 1 of the year the certificate was issued (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov).

The sale itself is run by the Clerk. Florida law lets a clerk conduct electronic tax deed sales instead of public outcry (section 197.542(4)(a), flsenate.gov). The Clay Clerk says all of its sales are held online and that you have to create an online account to take part (Clay Clerk). Check the Clerk's site for the current opening bid, because the Clerk notes that the amount on the notice can change before the sale.

The part most people miss

Under section 197.552, no right, interest, restriction or covenant survives a tax deed, with one exception. A lien of record held by a municipal or county governmental unit, a special district or a community development district survives if it is not satisfied when the sale proceeds are disbursed (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov). In plain English, a lien held by the county or city can still be there after you win the auction, if the sale money did not pay it off.

That is exactly the thing I warned about on camera. Houses sold for taxes sometimes carry code enforcement violations, and some of those violations carry fines. I am not quoting a statistic, and every house is different. I am telling you that a house bought for a small opening bid can cost far more once you add what a lien or a list of violations demands. The math box below shows how a daily fine adds up, using made-up numbers.

Here is what I told viewers to do before they bid:

  1. Order a title search, or talk to a title company about what a search shows.
  2. Check with the county and the city for open code cases and recorded liens.
  3. Be honest about your resources. Do you have the labor, tools, a yard crew or the budget to clear the violations?
  4. Remember that you may be the next person who has to resell it. If violations follow the property, it is hard to sell, because nobody wants to buy someone else's open violations.

I have seen clients buy a property like this and then feel stuck with it for a long time, putting in more money than they planned. I am not saying that happens every time. I am saying it is common enough that I would never skip the checks.

How Code Enforcement Fines and Liens Work

Since liens came up, here is how the main Florida code enforcement statute reads. Section 162.09 covers the penalties a local code enforcement board can impose.

  • Daily fines. A fine may not exceed $250 per day for a first violation and $500 per day for a repeat violation, plus repair costs. If the board finds the violation irreparable or irreversible, it may impose up to $5,000 per violation (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov).
  • Higher local limits. A county or municipality with a population of 50,000 or more may adopt an ordinance allowing higher fines, up to $1,000 per day for a first violation and $5,000 per day for a repeat violation, and up to $15,000 per violation if irreparable or irreversible (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov).
  • The board can reduce a fine. Section 162.09(2)(c) says an enforcement board may reduce a fine (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov). That helps explain why I said, in the video, that the amount can depend on what you invest to bring the property into compliance. The outcome is up to the local board, so I would never promise a reduction.
  • Recorded orders become liens. A certified copy of an order imposing a fine may be recorded, and it then constitutes a lien on the land where the violation exists and on other real or personal property the violator owns. The fine keeps accruing until the violator complies or a suit is decided (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov).
  • Homestead. Under the same section, a lien under this part may not be foreclosed on real property that is a homestead under Article X, section 4 of the Florida Constitution (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov). That is about homestead property. An investor-owned house is generally a different story, so I treat any recorded lien as real until a title company tells me otherwise.

If you own a house with open code violations and you are thinking about selling, call your city or county code office first. Ask what is open and what it would take to close each item. Then compare selling as-is with fixing first. A direct buyer may be willing to take the house as-is, but the lien will still be priced in.

Checking a For Sale By Owner Sign

On the same drive I stopped at a For Sale By Owner sign on a house that was not showing on Zillow or the MLS. I called the number on the sign. Then I looked up the property records to see whether the name on the sign matched the owner of record. After that, I knocked on the door and left a door hanger.

Why check? Because anyone can put a sign in a yard. Before I talk numbers with anyone, I want to know I am dealing with the person who owns the house, or someone with legal authority to sign for them.

Fraud is a real risk

The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center warned on June 16, 2026 about criminals who impersonate the owners of vacant property parcels and try to sell them without the owner knowing (FBI IC3 PSA260616). The title industry group ALTA reported on the warning on June 18, 2026 (ALTA). That warning is about vacant land, not houses with people living in them, but the lesson carries over. Verify the seller before you spend money.

If you own property, both the Clay County Clerk and the Duval County Clerk offer a free Property Fraud Alert. It sends you a notice when a document is recorded that matches a name you register (Clay Clerk, Duval Clerk). The Clay Clerk is clear that the alert does not stop a fraudulent filing. It gives you a chance to act sooner.

What the national numbers say about selling on your own

According to the National Association of Realtors' 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, 5% of sales were For Sale By Owner, a record low, while 91% of sellers used an agent (NAR, NAR profile summary). NAR is a trade association for agents, and I am a licensed agent, so keep that in mind when you read it. I am not saying you cannot sell on your own. I am saying serious buyers will look up the records, so make sure whoever signs has the authority.

What People Believe and What Is True

What people believe: A cheap tax deed house is a bargain.

What is true: It can be, but a county or city lien of record can survive the tax deed if it is not paid from the sale proceeds (section 197.552). Check first.

What people believe: Foreclosure can start the first month you miss a payment.

What is true: Under the federal rule, a servicer generally cannot make the first foreclosure filing until you are more than 120 days delinquent, with some exceptions (12 CFR 1024.41(f)).

What people believe: If I get a summons, I have plenty of time.

What is true: The answer deadline is generally 20 days after service (Rule 1.140).

What people believe: A short sale wipes out what I owe.

What is true: Not unless the lender agrees. The CFPB says to ask for a written waiver of the deficiency (CFPB), and Florida limits deficiencies on owner-occupied homes under section 702.06 (statute).

What people believe: Code fines always get reduced if you fix the problem.

What is true: A board may reduce a fine, but it is not required to (section 162.09(2)(c)).

What people believe: A sign in the yard means the person is the owner.

What is true: Check the owner of record in the property records first.

A First Steps Checklist

If you are in a spot like the first homeowner in this video, here is the order I would work in. It is not a promise of an outcome. It is a way to stay organized.

  1. Read every letter from your servicer, and call the servicer to ask what options exist for your loan. Write down the date, the name and what was said.
  2. Call a HUD-approved housing counseling agency. The CFPB lists (855) 411-2372 to be connected to one.
  3. Ask your servicer for a written payoff figure, so you know exactly what is owed.
  4. Get an honest opinion of value, both as is and after repairs, from more than one person.
  5. Figure out where you will live next before you commit to a sale date.
  6. Compare a listing with a direct sale, using your own numbers and the closing costs in section 5.
  7. If you are served with a lawsuit, calendar the 20 day deadline and contact a Florida attorney or legal aid right away.
  8. If a short sale or deed in lieu is on the table, ask for a written deficiency waiver.
  9. If you are buying a house from a tax deed sale instead, order a title search and check the city and county for open violations first.
  10. Before wiring any money at a closing, confirm the instructions by phone, using a number you already trust. The CFPB advises confirming instructions with your trusted representatives and being careful about closing details sent by email (CFPB).

Frequently Asked Questions

How long can I be behind on my mortgage before foreclosure starts?

Under the federal servicing rule, a servicer generally may not make the first foreclosure notice or filing until your loan is more than 120 days delinquent, with a few exceptions such as a due-on-sale violation (CFPB, 12 CFR 1024.41(f), CFPB). Your own loan documents control the details.

How long do I have to respond to a Florida foreclosure lawsuit?

Generally 20 days after you are served with the summons and complaint (Rule 1.140, Florida Law Help, Duval Clerk). If you miss it, the lender may win by default. Talk to an attorney or legal aid office right away.

Can I stop a Florida foreclosure sale by paying?

Under section 45.0315, before the later of the clerk filing a certificate of sale or the time set in the judgment, the mortgagor or a holder of a subordinate interest may cure the debt and prevent the sale by paying the amount in the judgment (statute, Senate copy). After that, there is no right of redemption.

What is a short sale, and will I owe the difference?

A short sale is a sale for less than you owe, with lender approval. The CFPB says to ask for a written waiver of any deficiency (CFPB). Florida limits a deficiency on owner-occupied homes under section 702.06 (statute). Ask an attorney how it applies to you.

Does a tax deed wipe out every lien on a Florida property?

No. Under section 197.552, a lien of record held by a municipal or county governmental unit, a special district or a community development district survives the tax deed if it is not satisfied when the sale proceeds are disbursed (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov). Check for liens before you bid.

How high can code enforcement fines go in Florida?

Section 162.09 sets a general cap of $250 per day for a first violation and $500 per day for a repeat violation, up to $5,000 for an irreparable violation. Counties and cities with 50,000 or more people may adopt higher limits by ordinance (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov).

Can a code enforcement board reduce a fine?

Yes, under section 162.09(2)(c), an enforcement board may reduce a fine. It is up to the board, so do not count on it (leg.state.fl.us, flsenate.gov).

Are Clay County tax deed sales held online?

The Clay County Clerk says all of its tax deed sales are held online and bidders must create an online account (Clay Clerk). Florida law allows clerks to conduct electronic tax deed sales (section 197.542(4)(a), Senate copy).

What does documentary stamp tax cost on a Florida deed?

Section 201.02 sets 70 cents per $100 of consideration, and the Department of Revenue says Miami-Dade County is the exception with a lower rate (statute, Florida DOR). Any party to the deed can be liable, so the contract should say who pays (DOR FAQ).

How do I know a For Sale By Owner seller really owns the house?

Look up the owner of record in the county property records and compare the name. The FBI has warned about criminals who impersonate property owners (FBI IC3). The Clay and Duval Clerks both offer a free Property Fraud Alert for owners (Clay, Duval).

Sources and Data Dates

Every legal and numeric fact above was checked against at least two sources in October 2026. Official sources come first. Links were accessed on the dates shown, between Oct 27 and Oct 28, 2026.

  1. NEFAR, Northeast Florida housing market, September 2026 (released Oct 8, 2026)
  2. Fleming Island and Orange Park Times, Clay County home prices fall 4.1% (reports the NEFAR September 2026 data)
  3. Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey (30 year rate 7.32% as of Oct 22, 2026)
  4. FRED, 30-Year Fixed Rate Mortgage Average (MORTGAGE30US) (updated Oct 22, 2026; republishes Freddie Mac data)
  5. CFPB, 12 CFR 1024.41 Loss mitigation procedures (accessed Oct 2026)
  6. CFPB, How long will it take before I face foreclosure? (accessed Oct 2026)
  7. Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 1.140 (Oct 1, 2026 edition, The Florida Bar) (rules in effect Oct 1, 2026)
  8. Florida Law Help, Foreclosures (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  9. Duval County Clerk, Foreclosure (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  10. Florida Statutes section 45.0315 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  11. Florida Statutes section 45.0315 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  12. CFPB, What is a short sale? (accessed Oct 2026)
  13. CFPB, What is a deed in lieu of foreclosure? (accessed Oct 2026)
  14. 24 CFR 203.357, Deed in lieu of foreclosure (Cornell LII) (federal rule for FHA insured loans)
  15. Florida Statutes section 702.06 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  16. Florida Statutes section 702.06 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  17. Florida Statutes section 201.02 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  18. Florida Statutes section 201.02 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  19. Florida DOR, Documentary Stamp Tax (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  20. Florida DOR FAQ, Which party to a taxable transaction is liable for documentary stamp tax? (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  21. Fla. Admin. Code r. 69O-186.003, Title Insurance Rates (Cornell LII) (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  22. Florida CFO, Title Insurance Overview (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  23. Florida Statutes section 197.333 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  24. Florida Statutes section 197.333 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  25. Clay County Clerk of Court, Tax Deeds (accessed Oct 2026)
  26. Florida Statutes section 197.502 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  27. Florida Statutes section 197.502 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  28. Florida Statutes section 197.542 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  29. Florida Statutes section 197.542 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  30. Florida Statutes section 197.552 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  31. Florida Statutes section 197.552 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  32. Florida Statutes section 162.09 (Online Sunshine, leg.state.fl.us) (official statute text)
  33. Florida Statutes section 162.09 (Florida Senate) (official statute text, 2026)
  34. FBI IC3, Public Service Announcement PSA260616 (dated June 16, 2026)
  35. ALTA, wire fraud and title scam alert (item dated June 18, 2026)
  36. Clay County Clerk, Property Fraud Alert Service (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  37. Duval County Clerk, Property Fraud Alert (accessed Oct 27, 2026)
  38. NAR, FSBOs Reach All-Time Low, More Sellers Rely on Agents (NAR 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers; NAR is a trade association)
  39. NAR, 2025 Profile of Home Buyers, Sellers Reveals Market Extremes (NAR; trade association)
  40. CFPB, Mortgage closing scams: how to protect yourself and your closing funds (CFPB archived blog post)
  41. 12 CFR 1024.31, definitions for the mortgage servicing rules (delinquency) (free reference copy, not the official text, accessed Oct 2026)

I am not an attorney, and this article is not legal or financial advice. Laws, rates and market numbers change, so confirm anything that affects your own house with a Florida attorney, a HUD-approved housing counselor, a tax professional or your title company. If you want to talk it through, call or text me at 904-606-9163, email chris@webuyanyhouseinflorida.com or request a cash offer here.

Chris Moore is a licensed Florida real estate sales associate (Florida DBPR license SL3389080) with Momentum Realty. When We Buy Any House In Florida makes a cash offer, it is buying for its own account, not acting as your agent. This article is general information and is not legal or financial advice.

Connect with us: Facebook · Instagram · YouTube

Have a Question About
Your Situation?

Get honest guidance on where you stand, or a no-obligation cash offer to compare. Call 904-606-9163 or email chris@webuyanyhouseinflorida.com. No pressure.

Explore Northeast Florida Home Selling Resources

Serving Duval, Clay, St. Johns, Baker, Putnam, Nassau, and Bradford counties.

Guides and Tools

We Buy Houses by Area

Stop Foreclosure by City

Probate House Sale by County

Inherited Property

Code Violations

Divorce

Behind on Payments

Needs Repairs

Short Sale

Rental with Tenants

Vacant House

Tax Liens

Fire Damaged

Bankruptcy

Official Sources

Call Chris Text Get Offer